Thirteen gums, rankedSeven measured scores.

Which nicotine gum scores best?

Nicorette scores 4.0 of 5 and Amazon Basic Care scores 3.9.

Eight gums have enough data to rank. Five do not have a buyer rating that we could read at a store.

PriceFlavorsLabelRatingTastePocketBuyingOverall

1

NicoretteHaleon · $0.31 a piece25543454.02

Amazon Basic CarePerrigo · $0.17 a piece45532443.93

Target up&upPerrigo · $0.23 a piece3553–433.84

RugbyP&L Development · $0.20 a piece44531443.65

BlipPerrigo · $0.40 a piece22234453.16

Kirkland Signature QuitPerrigo · $0.16 a piece42542223.06

QuitinePerrigo · $0.20 a piece43332243.08

HabitrolP&L Development · $0.33 a piece2242–242.7–

EquateNot ranked: no buyer rating read at a store3554–43––

WalgreensNot ranked: no buyer rating read at a store255––43––

Lucy Quit GumNot ranked: no buyer rating read at a store224––55––

CVS HealthNot ranked: no buyer rating read at a store244––43––

Lucy GumNot ranked: no buyer rating read at a store253––51–

Overall is the mean of the scores that exist, each from 1 to 5. A gum needs five scores and a buyer rating read at a store to rank. Taste counts what buyers wrote, because we have not tested the gums yet.